—
For fly fishermen, the meditative art of fly tying is crucial. It’s where ingenuity meets necessity, and success hinges on the quality of your materials and tools.
A dependable fly tying vice is arguably the most important piece of equipment. It’s the bedrock upon which every fly is built, securing your hook and allowing for precise manipulation of materials.
Choosing the best fly tying vices can dramatically impact your tying experience, affecting both the ease of use and the final product. With a vast array of options available, selecting the right vice can be overwhelming.
This review aims to simplify the process, focusing on key features, durability, and overall value. We understand that investing in the best fly tying vices is an investment in your craft.
—
IN THIS ARTICLE
Top 10 Fly Tying Vices Compared
Super AA Fly Tying Vise
- 360-degree rotation for easy fly access.
- All-purpose vise suitable for various fly tying needs.
- Easy to operate, potentially beginner-friendly.
- Suitable for all skill levels.
4.3/5
Check Price on Amazon
LURELINK Rotary-Fly-Tying-Vise-Fly-Tying-Tools Equ
- Securely holds hooks of various sizes.
- Smooth 360-degree rotation for efficient tying.
- Adjustable tension for personalized control.
- Durable construction for long-lasting use.
4.8/5
Check Price on Amazon
Black Crown Vise
- Accommodates a wide range of hook sizes (4/0 to 22).
- Lever-action jaws for quick and easy hook changes.
- Secure hook holding.
- Heavy base provides stability.
4.5/5
Check Price on Amazon
Kingfisher Fly Fishing Clarkfork True Rotary Fly Tying Vise
- Improved riser design addresses wobble issues.
- Smooth and balanced rotary function with two ball bearings.
- Versatile jaws accommodate hook sizes 26 to 4/0.
- Durable construction using hard anodized marine-grade aluminum.
4.6/5
Check Price on Amazon
Rotary Fly Tying Vise – Peak Fishing Vise With Ped
- Durable construction using high-quality materials.
- Versatile hook holding capability (2/0 to very small).
- Stable pedestal base with non-marking feet.
- White powder-coated base for enhanced material visibility.
4.4/5
Check Price on Amazon
Colorado Anglers – Fly Tying Standard Tool Kit with Wooden Box & Book
- Complete starter kit with essential tools and materials.
- Rotary vise allows for precise fly tying.
- Wooden box provides organized storage.
- Versatile material selection for various fly patterns.
4.4/5
Check Price on Amazon
Nirvana V2 Rotary Fly Tying Vise with Travel Base
- Strong and durable jaws securely hold hooks.
- Smooth rotary bearing system with adjustable tension.
- Easy-to-use rotary handle for precise control.
- Fully adjustable for various hook sizes.
4.7/5
Check Price on Amazon
Kingfisher Fly Tying Clarkfork Fly Tying Vise Kit
- Smooth rotary action with dual ball bearings.
- Versatile jaw accommodates hook sizes 26 to 4/0.
- Durable anodized marine-grade aluminum construction.
- Includes a complete fly tying tool kit.
4.5/5
Check Price on Amazon
Maxcatch Rotary Fly Tying Vise Alloy Travel Vise (
- Full rotary action
- Adjustable rotary tension
- Wide jaw capacity (size 28 to 4/0)
- Hardened-steel jaws
4.6/5
Check Price on Amazon
Fly Tying Vise with Bench Clip – Metal Fly Tying T
- Durable stainless steel and brass construction.
- Hardened tool steel jaws provide a secure hook grip.
- Adjustable design accommodates various fly patterns.
- Deep rabbet design to minimize rocking.
4.6/5
Check Price on Amazon
Detailed Reviews of the Best Fly Tying Vices
Super AA Fly Tying Vise – 360-degree rotation for easy fly access.
The Super AA Fly Tying Vise is presented as an all-purpose vise suitable for fly tying at all skill levels. Its key feature is its 360-degree rotation, which should allow for convenient access to all sides of the fly being tied. The description emphasizes ease of operation, suggesting it’s user-friendly even for beginners.
The limited description doesn’t provide details about the materials used in its construction or its overall durability, which are important factors for serious fly tyers. While the ‘Super’ prefix suggests high quality, further information regarding its clamping mechanism and suitability for different hook sizes would be beneficial for potential buyers. Overall, it seems geared towards beginners or intermediate users.
Pros
- 360-degree rotation for easy fly access.
- All-purpose vise suitable for various fly tying needs.
- Easy to operate, potentially beginner-friendly.
- Suitable for all skill levels.
Cons
- Limited information on material quality and durability.
- Lack of detail regarding clamping mechanism and hook size compatibility.
LURELINK Rotary-Fly-Tying-Vise-Fly-Tying-Tools Equ – Securely holds hooks of various sizes.
The Rotary Fly Tying Vise appears to be a solid option for fly tiers of varying skill levels. The grip mechanism effectively holds hooks ranging from small sizes to larger 4/0s, minimizing slippage. The 360-degree rotation is a welcome feature for intricate tying, allowing for efficient and precise work.
The adjustable tension allows for customization based on individual tying styles and preferences. The vise seems durable based on the description, suggesting it can withstand regular use and travel. The universal design and spare parts are a bonus, catering to a wide range of fly sizes and ensuring longevity.
Overall, this vise offers a good balance of functionality and durability.
Pros
- Securely holds hooks of various sizes.
- Smooth 360-degree rotation for efficient tying.
- Adjustable tension for personalized control.
- Durable construction for long-lasting use.
- Universal design accommodates various fly sizes.
- Includes spare parts for wearing parts.
Cons
- Long-term durability is based on a single user experience and may vary.
- Performance might be inferior to top-tier vises that cost significantly more.
Black Crown Vise – Accommodates a wide range of hook sizes (4/0 to 22).
The Black Crown Vise appears to be a capable fly-tying vise suitable for both beginners and experienced tiers. Its ability to handle a wide range of hook sizes, from 4/0 down to size 22, makes it versatile for various fly patterns. The lever-action jaw mechanism simplifies hook changes, and the vise provides a secure grip on the hook during tying.
The black finish gives it a sleek look, and the heavy base offers stability, allowing you to tie flies without needing to clamp it to a desk. The adjustable jaw angle enhances usability, permitting customization to your preferred tying position.
Pros
- Accommodates a wide range of hook sizes (4/0 to 22).
- Lever-action jaws for quick and easy hook changes.
- Secure hook holding.
- Heavy base provides stability.
- Adjustable jaw angle (up/down and 360 degrees).
Cons
- Black finish might show scratches or wear over time.
- May be bulky for travel due to heavy base.
Kingfisher Fly Fishing Clarkfork True Rotary Fly Tying Vise – Improved riser design addresses wobble issues.
The Kingfisher Fly Fishing vise appears to be a solid option for fly tying enthusiasts. The updated riser, designed to address previous wobble issues, is a welcome improvement. The rotary function, utilizing two ball bearings, promises smooth and balanced operation, which is crucial for precise tying.
The hardened steel jaws, accommodating hook sizes from 26 to 4/0, offer versatility for various fly patterns. The use of hard anodized marine-grade aluminum for key components suggests durability and resistance to corrosion, important for longevity. The fact that this vise comes from an established fly shop run by experienced fishing guides adds a level of credibility and understanding of what tyers need.
However, the aluminum construction, while durable, might not offer the same weighty stability as a steel vise.
Pros
- Improved riser design addresses wobble issues.
- Smooth and balanced rotary function with two ball bearings.
- Versatile jaws accommodate hook sizes 26 to 4/0.
- Durable construction using hard anodized marine-grade aluminum.
- Backed by an established fly shop with experienced fishing guides.
Cons
- Aluminum construction may be less weighty/stable compared to steel vises.
Rotary Fly Tying Vise – Peak Fishing Vise With Ped – Durable construction using high-quality materials.
The Peak Rotary Vise appears to be a well-constructed tool for fly tying, utilizing durable materials like stainless steel, brass, tool steel, and aircraft aluminum which suggests long-term reliability. Its hardened steel jaws offer a wide hook size range, accommodating sizes from 2/0 down to very small hooks. The large pedestal base provides stability and features non-marking feet to prevent damage to surfaces.
The powder-coated white base enhances visibility of materials and includes a convenient integrated hook/bead pocket. While the description highlights durability and ease of use, the absence of an included accessory post might be a drawback for some users. Overall, it seems like a solid choice for both beginners and experienced fly tiers.
Pros
- Durable construction using high-quality materials.
- Versatile hook holding capability (2/0 to very small).
- Stable pedestal base with non-marking feet.
- White powder-coated base for enhanced material visibility.
- Integrated hook/bead pocket for convenience.
Cons
- Accessory post not included.
Colorado Anglers – Fly Tying Standard Tool Kit with Wooden Box & Book – Complete starter kit with essential tools and materials.
The Colorado Anglers Fly Tying Kit offers a comprehensive entry point for beginners and a convenient package for experienced fly tiers. The kit includes a rotary vise, bobbin, scissors, whip finisher, and a selection of essential materials, all neatly organized in a wooden box. The rotary vise allows for 360-degree rotation, aiding in precise detailing.
The included tools appear functional and suitable for creating a variety of fly patterns. The assortment of materials such as feathers, furs, threads, and synthetics provides ample opportunity for experimentation. The addition of head cement is a thoughtful touch.
While the quality of individual components may not match professional-grade standalone tools, the kit presents a valuable all-in-one solution for getting started or maintaining a mobile fly tying setup.
Pros
- Complete starter kit with essential tools and materials.
- Rotary vise allows for precise fly tying.
- Wooden box provides organized storage.
- Versatile material selection for various fly patterns.
- Includes head cement for fly durability.
Cons
- The quality of included tools and materials might not match professional-grade individual components.
- Rotary vise may not be suitable for the most demanding professional use.
Nirvana V2 Rotary Fly Tying Vise with Travel Base – Strong and durable jaws securely hold hooks.
This fly tying vise offers several features aimed at improving the tying experience. The improved jaws appear robust and capable of securely holding hooks. The smooth rotary bearing system, coupled with adjustable tension, allows for comfortable and controlled rotation, which is essential for many tying techniques.
The easy-to-use rotary handle enhances this control. The vise’s adjustability is a key selling point, catering to a wide array of hook sizes. The inclusion of a premium pedestal base with a sure-lock stem is a nice bonus, providing a stable platform.
Initial impressions suggest a well-designed tool for fly tying enthusiasts of varying skill levels.
Pros
- Strong and durable jaws securely hold hooks.
- Smooth rotary bearing system with adjustable tension.
- Easy-to-use rotary handle for precise control.
- Fully adjustable for various hook sizes.
- Premium pedestal base included for stability.
Cons
- May require some fine-tuning to find the optimal tension setting.
- The specific materials used in construction aren’t explicitly stated, so long-term durability remains to be fully tested.
Kingfisher Fly Tying Clarkfork Fly Tying Vise Kit – Smooth rotary action with dual ball bearings.
The Kingfisher Fly Fishing rotary vise appears to be a solid option for fly tiers of various skill levels. The rotary function, supported by two ball bearings, is advertised as exceptionally smooth, which is a crucial feature for intricate tying techniques. The hardened steel jaws accommodate a wide range of hook sizes, from small #26 to large #4/0, offering versatility.
The use of anodized marine-grade aluminum for key components suggests durability and corrosion resistance. Furthermore, the inclusion of a complete fly tying tool kit adds value. Being a product of Kingfisher Fly Shop in Missoula, Montana, inspires confidence related to fly fishing expertise.
Pros
- Smooth rotary action with dual ball bearings.
- Versatile jaw accommodates hook sizes 26 to 4/0.
- Durable anodized marine-grade aluminum construction.
- Includes a complete fly tying tool kit.
- Backed by The Kingfisher Fly Shop, a reputable fly fishing retailer.
Cons
- The tool kit’s quality may vary; individual tool quality not detailed.
- The base is not specified, might need an upgrade for certain users
Maxcatch Rotary Fly Tying Vise Alloy Travel Vise ( – Full rotary action
This fly tying vise offers a full rotary action, which is a desirable feature for experienced fly tiers. The adjustable rotary tension allows for customization and control during fly creation. The jaw capacity, ranging from size 28 to 4/0, appears versatile enough to handle a wide variety of hook sizes.
The hardened-steel jaws should provide durability and secure hook holding. Its portability, facilitated by the heavy base and packaging in a plastic box, makes it convenient for tying flies on the go. However, the product description lacks specific details about the quality of the materials and the smoothness of the rotary action.
More information regarding the vise’s longevity and ease of use would be beneficial.
Pros
- Full rotary action
- Adjustable rotary tension
- Wide jaw capacity (size 28 to 4/0)
- Hardened-steel jaws
- Portable with heavy base and plastic box
Cons
- Limited detail on material quality and smoothness of rotary action
- Durability might be a concern.
Fly Tying Vise with Bench Clip – Metal Fly Tying T – Durable stainless steel and brass construction.
This fly tying vise appears to be a solid option for both beginner and experienced fly tyers. The combination of stainless steel and brass construction suggests durability, while the inclusion of tool steel jaws implies a secure grip on hooks of various sizes. The vise is advertised as being adjustable, allowing for the creation of different fly patterns, including teasers and jigs.
The deep rabbet design aims to prevent rocking during use, which is a definite plus for maintaining precision. The cast iron clamp ensures the vise is securely attached to the work surface. Overall, this vise seems to offer a good balance of functionality and stability for fly tying enthusiasts.
Pros
- Durable stainless steel and brass construction.
- Hardened tool steel jaws provide a secure hook grip.
- Adjustable design accommodates various fly patterns.
- Deep rabbet design to minimize rocking.
- Cast iron clamp ensures stable mounting.
Cons
- The cast iron clamp might be heavy for some users.
- May require careful adjustment for optimal hook holding.
Buying Guide: What to Look For in a Fly Tying Vices
Understanding Fly Tying Vises
Choosing the best fly tying vise depends on your needs and budget. A vise is the cornerstone of your fly tying setup, securely holding the hook while you add materials to create your desired fly pattern. Key features to consider include the vise’s holding power, rotary function, jaw capacity, durability, and stability. Different vises cater to different skill levels, from beginner-friendly models to professional-grade rotary vises. Investing in a quality vise will significantly improve your fly tying experience.
Key Features to Consider
* Jaw Capacity: The range of hook sizes the vise can accommodate. Consider the sizes of flies you typically tie.
* Rotary Function: Allows you to rotate the fly 360 degrees, making it easier to apply materials from all angles. True rotary vises rotate on the hook’s axis for perfect symmetry.
* Holding Power: The vise must securely grip the hook without slipping or damaging it.
* Durability: Look for vises made from high-quality materials like stainless steel or hardened steel for longevity.
* Stability: A heavy base or clamp-on design will prevent the vise from moving while you’re tying.
* Adjustability: The ability to adjust the jaw angle and tension allows for customization and comfort.
* Beginner-Friendly vs. Advanced: Some vises are designed for beginners with simple operation, while others offer more advanced features for experienced tiers.
Types of Fly Tying Vises
There are several types of fly tying vises available, each with its own advantages and disadvantages.
* C-Clamp Vises: These vises clamp onto a table or workbench. They are generally more portable than pedestal vises.
* Pedestal Vises: These vises have a heavy base that provides stability. They are ideal for tying at a dedicated workstation.
* Rotary Vises: These vises allow you to rotate the fly 360 degrees. They are more expensive but offer greater control and efficiency.
* In-Line Rotary Vises: A type of rotary vise that rotates the hook around its shank, giving true rotation.
Choosing the Best Fly Tying Vise for Your Needs
Consider your skill level, the types of flies you tie, and your budget when choosing a fly tying vise. Beginners may want to start with a simple, affordable vise, while experienced tiers may want to invest in a high-quality rotary vise. Look for a vise that is durable, stable, and easy to use. The best fly tying vise is the one that meets your specific needs and preferences.
Frequently Asked Questions about Fly Tying Vices
What is a rotary fly tying vise, and why is it beneficial?
A rotary fly tying vise allows the tier to rotate the hook 360 degrees along its axis. This is beneficial because it allows for even distribution of materials around the hook shank, creating more symmetrical and durable flies. It also simplifies techniques like applying epoxy or building up bodies. While not essential for all fly tying, a rotary vise significantly enhances efficiency and precision, making it a worthwhile investment for serious tiers, especially when working on complex patterns or large batches of flies.
What hook sizes should my fly tying vise accommodate?
The range of hook sizes your vise should accommodate depends on the types of flies you plan to tie. If you tie small midges, you’ll need a vise that can securely hold hooks as small as size 28 or 32. For larger streamer patterns, you’ll need a vise that can handle hooks as large as size 4/0 or 6/0. A versatile vise that can accommodate a wide range of hook sizes (e.g., 28 to 4/0) is a good option for most tiers.
How important is the base of a fly tying vise?
The base of a fly tying vise is crucial for stability. A stable base prevents the vise from moving or wobbling while you’re tying, which can be frustrating and make it difficult to apply materials accurately. Pedestal bases are generally more stable than C-clamp bases, but they are also less portable. Look for a base that is heavy and has a non-slip surface. C-clamp bases must be firmly fixed to a sturdy surface.
What materials are considered durable for a fly tying vise?
The durability of a fly tying vise depends on the materials used in its construction. Stainless steel and hardened steel are excellent choices for the jaws, as they are strong and resistant to corrosion. Aluminum is a good choice for the body of the vise, as it is lightweight and durable. Look for vises with high-quality construction and materials to ensure that they will last for many years.
What should I look for in a beginner-friendly fly tying vise?
A beginner-friendly fly tying vise should be easy to use and adjust. Look for a vise with simple jaw operation, clear instructions, and a stable base. A vise that can accommodate a wide range of hook sizes is also a good choice for beginners, as it will allow you to experiment with different fly patterns. Don’t be afraid to start with a more affordable option as you learn the basics.
How do I maintain my fly tying vise to ensure its longevity?
Regular maintenance is essential for ensuring the longevity of your fly tying vise. After each tying session, clean the jaws of the vise with a soft cloth to remove any debris or glue. Occasionally, lubricate the moving parts of the vise with a light oil. Store the vise in a dry place to prevent corrosion. If you notice any damage to the jaws or other parts of the vise, repair or replace them promptly.
What is the difference between a cam jaw and a lever jaw vise?
Cam jaw and lever jaw mechanisms are two common designs for securing the hook in a fly tying vise. Cam jaws use a cam-shaped lever to apply pressure, offering strong holding power and quick operation. Lever jaws, on the other hand, use a simple lever action. Cam jaws are generally preferred for their superior grip and ease of use, especially with smaller hooks. Consider the type of flies you tie most often when choosing between these two jaw types.
Are fly tying vise kits worth the investment?
Fly tying vise kits can be a good option for beginners, as they typically include a vise, tools, and materials needed to get started. However, the quality of the vise and other components in a kit can vary widely. Before purchasing a kit, research the individual components to ensure that they are of decent quality. It may be more cost-effective to purchase a vise and tools separately, especially if you have specific preferences.
How do I choose between a C-clamp and a pedestal base vise?
The choice between a C-clamp and a pedestal base vise depends on your workspace and tying style. C-clamp vises are more portable and can be attached to any stable surface, making them ideal for tiers who move around frequently. Pedestal base vises offer greater stability but require a dedicated workstation. Consider the size and layout of your tying area when making your decision. If you have a permanent tying station, a pedestal base is generally preferred.
What is the ideal tension for the rotary function on my fly tying vise?
The ideal tension for the rotary function depends on your personal preference and the type of fly you are tying. Generally, you want enough tension to prevent the vise from rotating freely but not so much that it is difficult to turn. Experiment with different tension settings to find what works best for you. A smooth and easily adjustable rotary tension is a hallmark of the best fly tying vices.
Conclusion: The Final Verdict
The Super AA Fly Tying Vise appears to be a decent option, especially for beginners. However, more experienced fly tyers might want to seek a vise with more detailed specifications and higher-grade materials. Consider it if you need a simple, rotating vise at an entry-level price point.
