As the days grow shorter and the nights cooler, the allure of a cozy fireplace becomes undeniable. For those seeking the ambiance without the hassle of traditional wood-burning fireplaces, electric fireplace inserts offer a convenient and stylish solution.
However, with a vast array of options available, selecting the best electric fireplace inserts can be a daunting task. This guide is designed to simplify that process.
We understand the importance of finding an insert that balances quality, performance, and value. A poorly chosen insert can lead to disappointment, while the right one can transform your living space.
Therefore, we’ve focused on providing insights into what to look for when considering the best electric fireplace inserts, helping you make an informed decision and create a warm and inviting atmosphere in your home.
IN THIS ARTICLE
Top 5 Electric Fireplace Inserts Compared
Touchstone Smart Electric Fireplace-The Sideline 50″ Wide-in Wall Recessed – 30 Realistic Ember Color/Flame Options – 1
- Sleek black glass finish, modern rectangular shape.
- Vent-free, wall-mounted, easy to install indoors.
- Realistic log set, crystals, and driftwood included.
- Remote control for convenient temperature adjustments.
4.6/5
Check Price on Amazon
PuraFlame Western Electric Fireplace Insert with Fire Crackling Sound
- Heats up to 400 square feet efficiently.
- Adjustable settings for customized comfort and control.
- Freestanding, plug-in, or wall mount installation options.
- Traditional style with realistic flame effect.
4.7/5
Check Price on Amazon
60″ Electric Fireplace Wall Mounted and Recessed with Remote Control
- Modern style with 12 flame color options.
- Safety shut off feature for peace of mind.
- Remote and touch panel control convenience.
- Vent-free and wall-mounted for easy installation.
4.6/5
Check Price on Amazon
Silonn 50″Smart Electric Fireplace Heater with App & Remote Control
- Modern style and deep black color enhance decor.
- Multicolor LED flame provides ambiance and adjustable settings.
- Overheat protection and timer ensure safe operation.
- Vent-free design allows for easy wall mount installation.
4.3/5
Check Price on Amazon
Antarctic Star 42 Inch Electric Fireplace in-Wall Recessed and Wall Mounted
- Modern style and sleek black color.
- Adjustable thermostat and flame for customized comfort.
- Vent-free design allows for flexible installation.
- Provides supplemental heat for up to 400 square feet.
4.5/5
Check Price on Amazon
Detailed Reviews of the Best Electric Fireplace Inserts
Touchstone Smart Electric Fireplace-The Sideline 50″ Wide-in Wall Recessed – 30 Realistic Ember Color/Flame Options – 1 – Sleek black glass finish, modern rectangular shape.
To be frank, this fireplace presents a compelling option, balancing cost and aesthetics effectively. The Sideline flames are visually superior compared to other brands, and the availability of a 100″ model at a competitive price point, several hundred less than the competition, enhances its appeal. Purchasing through Prime and opting for the extra warranty provides added assurance.
The fireplace is delivered securely on a linear pallet, preventing damage and facilitating movement. While installation can be managed solo, it’s advisable to have assistance due to the unit’s size and weight. Upon initial testing, a grinding noise was detected, traced to a dislodged flame rod.
TouchStone’s responsive customer service provided a guide to rectify the issue, involving the removal of multiple screws to access and remount the rod. This appeared to be a quality control lapse at the factory level. Despite this initial inconvenience, the resolution was straightforward, avoiding the need for a return or service call.
This also provided valuable insight into the unit’s mechanics. Once properly installed, the fireplace creates a fantastic visual impact. The flames are remarkably realistic, and the option to use either fake crystals or faux wood adds to the aesthetic versatility.
The multiple dimming options, including the unique blue-only flame setting, are particularly appealing, offering a cool and unobtrusive ambiance for movie viewing.
Pros
- Sleek black glass finish, modern rectangular shape.
- Vent-free, wall-mounted, easy to install indoors.
- Realistic log set, crystals, and driftwood included.
- Remote control for convenient temperature adjustments.
- Provides supplemental heat for spaces up to 400 ft.
Cons
- Quality control issues exist
- Unit repair may be needed
PuraFlame Western Electric Fireplace Insert with Fire Crackling Sound – Heats up to 400 square feet efficiently.
Exploring the exceptional features of this electric fireplace reveals a product that consistently surpasses expectations. Despite initial hesitations about purchasing online, the fireplaces arrived promptly and were meticulously packaged, ensuring their pristine condition. The aesthetic appeal is remarkable, with a realistic log set and captivating flames that enhance the ambiance of any room. Beyond its visual charm, this fireplace offers impressive supplemental heat. While not intended as a primary heating source, its performance in this area has been surprisingly effective.
In a moderate climate, the fireplace has proven capable of raising the indoor temperature, creating a comfortable and inviting atmosphere. The heat output far exceeded initial anticipation. The fireplace boasts a user-friendly design with simple yet effective features. The flame settings are thoughtfully curated, offering a range of options without unnecessary complexity.
While the “cracking” sound effect may be considered a novelty, the overall functionality is straightforward and enjoyable. The remote control provides easy operation, and the fixed flame and log set colors contribute to a cohesive and pleasing aesthetic. It’s important to acknowledge the potential impact on electricity consumption. While the fireplaces have temporarily reduced reliance on a gas furnace, an increase in the electric bill is anticipated.
However, the overall satisfaction with the product’s appearance, heating capabilities, and ease of use make it a worthwhile investment.
Pros
- Heats up to 400 square feet efficiently.
- Adjustable settings for customized comfort and control.
- Freestanding, plug-in, or wall mount installation options.
- Traditional style with realistic flame effect.
- Includes remote control for easy operation.
Cons
- Remote is too simple
- Electric bill likely to increase
60″ Electric Fireplace Wall Mounted and Recessed with Remote Control – Modern style with 12 flame color options.
My take on this product is that it’s an excellent choice for anyone looking to enhance their living space with a stylish and functional fireplace. It is a suitable replacement for existing fireplaces, and its compact design makes it perfect for smaller spaces such as RVs. The unit boasts a range of features designed for optimal comfort and convenience.
With three heat settings and a timer, you can easily customize the warmth to your preference. The color-changing feature adds a touch of ambiance, while the overall design ensures it looks great in any setting. Installation is straightforward, and the product has a quality feel, indicating durability and longevity.
The fireplace functions as advertised, providing reliable performance. Additionally, it offers five different brightness settings, allowing you to adjust the light output to your liking. The included remote control provides effortless operation from the comfort of your chair, allowing you to adjust heat, brightness, color, and timer.
This fireplace offers a significant upgrade in terms of both aesthetics and functionality, exceeding expectations with its performance and features.
Pros
- Modern style with 12 flame color options.
- Safety shut off feature for peace of mind.
- Remote and touch panel control convenience.
- Vent-free and wall-mounted for easy installation.
- Heats up to 400 sq ft efficiently.
Cons
- Remote could be misplaced
- Brightness may be too much
Silonn 50″Smart Electric Fireplace Heater with App & Remote Control – Modern style and deep black color enhance decor.
My take on this product highlights several exceptional features and a commitment to service. This is a beautiful piece perfect for renovations, offering a wide array of color options to match any decor. Beyond its aesthetic appeal, it effectively puts out heat, ensuring a cozy and comfortable atmosphere.
The accompanying mobile app is user-friendly, providing convenient control over the unit. While initial setup requires a specific step of pressing and holding the button on the front after powering off, the process is straightforward. The app also includes a child lock feature, which must be enabled to power on the unit remotely.
Despite an initial concern regarding fan noise, which was discovered after the return window, the seller demonstrated outstanding customer service. They responded promptly, requesting proof of purchase and a video of the issue. After a series of email exchanges, they arranged to ship a new unit, showcasing their dedication to resolving any problems.
The responsiveness and cordiality of the service team were particularly noteworthy, especially considering the time difference. The seller’s willingness to send a replacement unit, allowing the original to be kept, further underscores their commitment to satisfaction. While awaiting the new unit, there is optimism that it will operate without the noise issue, solidifying the product as a top-tier choice.
Pros
- Modern style and deep black color enhance decor.
- Multicolor LED flame provides ambiance and adjustable settings.
- Overheat protection and timer ensure safe operation.
- Vent-free design allows for easy wall mount installation.
- Remote control and tool set offer convenient operation.
Cons
- Loud fan is quite distracting
- Child lock needed for app use
Antarctic Star 42 Inch Electric Fireplace in-Wall Recessed and Wall Mounted – Modern style and sleek black color.
Many users find this product to be a great value, especially when purchased at a discounted price. While some may have initially desired a larger size, this model’s compact dimensions proved ideal for installations with spatial constraints, such as those with architectural details like protruding stonework. Its adaptability allows for creative installation solutions.
Individuals have successfully integrated the unit into existing fireplaces by constructing custom enclosures, demonstrating its versatility. These enclosures can be easily built using readily available materials like 2x4s and thin wooden coverings, allowing for seamless integration into various design aesthetics. The ease of customization provides the opportunity to create a unique and personalized focal point.
The unit provides a pleasant ambiance with various flame colors and display options. While the heat output is moderate, it effectively contributes to warming a room over time, creating a cozy and inviting atmosphere. It is important to note that this product is designed to emulate the aesthetic appeal of a fireplace rather than replicate the intense heat of a traditional fire.
Therefore, it is well-suited for individuals seeking an attractive decorative element rather than a primary heat source. Its visual appeal can be further enhanced by incorporating complementary design elements, such as timber accents, to achieve a desired aesthetic. Overall, this product is highly recommended for individuals seeking a visually appealing and adaptable fireplace insert that offers a range of customizable features and a subtle warming effect.
Pros
- Modern style and sleek black color.
- Adjustable thermostat and flame for customized comfort.
- Vent-free design allows for flexible installation.
- Provides supplemental heat for up to 400 square feet.
- Multicolor LED flame creates a cozy ambiance.
Cons
- Doesn’t produce intense heat
- Takes some effort to install
Buying Guide: What to Look For in a Electric Fireplace Inserts
Understanding Electric Fireplace Inserts
Electric fireplace inserts are a convenient and stylish way to add warmth and ambiance to your home without the mess or hassle of traditional fireplaces. These inserts fit into existing fireplace openings or can be mounted on walls, offering a realistic flame effect and supplemental heat. The best electric fireplace inserts are energy-efficient, easy to install, and come in various styles to complement any decor. Choosing the right insert involves considering factors like size, heating capacity, style, and features.
Key Features to Consider
When selecting the best electric fireplace inserts, prioritize features that meet your specific needs. Heating capacity is crucial; look for inserts that can efficiently heat the intended space, typically measured in square footage (e.g., 400 sq ft). Consider the flame effect realism, color options, and media included (logs, crystals, driftwood). Installation flexibility (wall-mounted, recessed, freestanding) is another key factor. Finally, evaluate convenience features like remote control, adjustable thermostat, timer, and safety features like overheat protection.
Types of Installation
Electric fireplace inserts offer versatile installation options to suit different spaces and preferences. Wall-mounted inserts are easy to install and create a modern look. Recessed inserts provide a seamless, built-in appearance. Freestanding inserts offer portability and can be moved as needed. Vent-free designs are common, eliminating the need for venting or chimney modifications. Consider the ease of installation and the desired aesthetic when choosing the installation type for your best electric fireplace inserts.
Style and Design
The best electric fireplace inserts come in various styles, from traditional to modern. Traditional inserts often feature realistic log sets and classic designs, while modern inserts emphasize sleek lines, black glass finishes, and multicolor LED flames. Choose an insert that complements your existing decor and personal style. Consider the color options, flame effects, and included media to create the desired ambiance. The style and design of your electric fireplace insert can significantly impact the overall look and feel of your space.
Frequently Asked Questions about Electric Fireplace Inserts
What are the benefits of choosing an electric fireplace insert over a traditional fireplace?
Electric fireplace inserts offer several advantages over traditional fireplaces. They are vent-free, eliminating the need for costly chimney installations or modifications. They are also more energy-efficient, providing supplemental heat without the energy loss associated with traditional fireplaces. Electric inserts are easy to install, operate, and maintain, offering a convenient and clean alternative to wood-burning fireplaces. The best electric fireplace inserts provide realistic flame effects without the mess or safety concerns of real flames.
How do I determine the appropriate size electric fireplace insert for my room?
To determine the appropriate size, measure the width and height of your existing fireplace opening or the wall space where you plan to install the insert. Consider the heating capacity of the insert, typically measured in square footage. A general rule is to choose an insert that can heat the entire room, but avoid oversizing, which can lead to excessive energy consumption. Many best electric fireplace inserts are designed to heat up to 400 square feet efficiently.
What is the difference between a wall-mounted and a recessed electric fireplace insert?
A wall-mounted electric fireplace insert is designed to be hung directly on the wall, similar to a picture frame. It protrudes slightly from the wall and is easy to install. A recessed electric fireplace insert, on the other hand, is designed to be installed within a wall opening, creating a flush, built-in appearance. Recessed inserts require more preparation and installation work but offer a cleaner, more integrated look. Both are great options for the best electric fireplace inserts.
Are electric fireplace inserts energy-efficient, and how much do they cost to operate?
Electric fireplace inserts are generally energy-efficient, especially compared to traditional fireplaces. They use LED technology for the flame effect, which consumes very little energy. The heating element consumes more power, but you can adjust the thermostat to control energy usage. The cost to operate depends on your electricity rate and usage. The best electric fireplace inserts offer adjustable settings to optimize energy efficiency and minimize operating costs.
What safety features should I look for in an electric fireplace insert?
Safety is paramount when choosing an electric fireplace insert. Look for models with overheat protection, which automatically shuts off the unit if it gets too hot. Consider inserts with cool-to-the-touch glass fronts to prevent burns. A timer function is also helpful for automatically turning off the fireplace after a set period. These safety features provide peace of mind and ensure safe operation of your best electric fireplace inserts.
Can I use an electric fireplace insert as my primary heat source?
While electric fireplace inserts can provide supplemental heat and create a cozy ambiance, they are generally not designed to be a primary heat source for an entire home. They are most effective for heating smaller spaces, such as living rooms or bedrooms. If you need a primary heat source, consider a central heating system or other dedicated heating appliances. The best electric fireplace inserts are excellent for supplemental heating and adding warmth to specific areas.
How realistic are the flame effects of electric fireplace inserts?
Modern electric fireplace inserts utilize advanced LED technology to create realistic flame effects. Some models offer multiple flame color options, adjustable brightness, and flickering patterns to mimic the look of a real fire. The inclusion of realistic log sets, crystals, or driftwood further enhances the visual appeal. While the flame effect is not identical to a real fire, it provides a convincing and aesthetically pleasing alternative. Many consider this one of the best things about electric fireplace inserts.
What maintenance is required for an electric fireplace insert?
Electric fireplace inserts require minimal maintenance compared to traditional fireplaces. The primary maintenance task is to periodically clean the glass front to remove dust or smudges. You may also need to occasionally replace the LED bulbs or other components, depending on the model. Regular cleaning and occasional maintenance will help ensure that your electric fireplace insert continues to operate efficiently and maintain its aesthetic appeal.
Do electric fireplace inserts come with a warranty?
Most electric fireplace inserts come with a manufacturer’s warranty, which typically covers defects in materials and workmanship. The warranty period can vary, ranging from one year to several years. Before purchasing an electric fireplace insert, carefully review the warranty terms and conditions to understand the coverage and any limitations. A comprehensive warranty provides added peace of mind and protection against potential issues.
Can I install an electric fireplace insert myself, or should I hire a professional?
The installation difficulty depends on the type of insert and your DIY skills. Wall-mounted inserts are generally easy to install with basic tools and following the manufacturer’s instructions. Recessed inserts may require more advanced skills and tools, as well as modifications to the wall structure. If you are unsure about any aspect of the installation process, it is always best to hire a qualified professional to ensure proper and safe installation of your best electric fireplace inserts.
Conclusion: The Final Verdict
After careful consideration of all the options, we believe the Touchstone Smart Electric Fireplace-The Sideline 50″ Wide-in Wall Recessed – 30 Realistic Ember Color/Flame Options – 1 stands out as the best overall choice for most users. It offers an excellent balance of features, performance, and value. Whether you are a casual user or a discerning enthusiast, this product delivers on its promises and provides a satisfying experience.
