—
For intricate woodworking projects, a scroll saw is an indispensable tool. But navigating the market to find the best scroll saws can be daunting.
The variance in quality and features across different models is significant, impacting everything from precision to ease of use. Selecting the right scroll saw can be the difference between a frustrating experience and a fulfilling creative process.
This review aims to simplify your decision-making process. We delve into the factors that contribute to a truly exceptional scroll saw, helping you identify the features that align with your specific needs and skill level.
We understand the importance of value and will guide you towards models that offer the optimal balance of performance, durability, and price. Ultimately, our goal is to ensure you invest in one of the best scroll saws to elevate your woodworking projects.
—
IN THIS ARTICLE
Top 10 Best Scroll Saws Compared
🏆 BEST OVERALL WEN Variable Speed Scroll Saw
- Accepts blades in two directions for increased ripping capacity.
- Variable speed control (400-1600 SPM) for versatile material cutting.
- Tilting table (up to 45 degrees) for angled cuts.
- Tool-free blade changes.
4.7/5
Check Price on Amazon
🥈 2ND RUNNER UP DEWALT Scroll Saw, 1.3 Amp
- Reduced vibration due to double parallel-link arm.
- Tool-free blade clamps for fast blade changes.
- Conveniently located front arm controls.
- Pivoting arm design promotes smoother operation.
4.4/5
Check Price on Amazon
� BEST VALUE WEN 3922 16-inch Variable Speed Scroll Saw with Ea
- Easy blade changes with side panel access and tool-free adapter.
- Variable speed control allows for versatility with different materials.
- Beveling table provides angled cutting capabilities.
- Cast iron base enhances stability.
4.3/5
Check Price on Amazon
WEN Variable Speed Scroll Saw
- Tool-free blade changes via side panel access
- Variable speed control for different materials
- Spacious table with beveling capability
- Adequate 16-inch throat depth
4.5/5
Check Price on Amazon
Shop Fox W1872 16″ VS Scroll Saw with Foot Switch
- Variable speed motor offers flexibility.
- 16-inch cutting width is suitable for larger projects.
- Tilting table for angled cuts.
- Includes dust port for dust collection.
4.6/5
Check Price on Amazon
FOXBC 5-Inch Scroll Saw Blade Pin End Replacement for Wen 3921 3923
- Wide compatibility with various scroll saw models.
- Includes a good assortment of TPI (10, 15, 18, 24) for versatile cutting.
- Constructed from SK5 Japanese carbon steel for improved strength and corrosion resistance.
- Easy to install and use.
4.7/5
Check Price on Amazon
WEN LL2156 21-Inch 1.6-Amp Variable Speed Parallel Arm Scroll Saw with Extra-Large Dual-Bevel Steel Table
- Parallel-arm design reduces vibration and noise.
- Tilting table provides versatility for angled cuts.
- Tool-free blade changes simplify the process.
- Variable speed motor allows for material-specific adjustments.
4.5/5
Check Price on Amazon
Hipicute 16-Inch Variable Speed Scroll Saw with Tilting Worktable (0-45°)
- Large adjustable worktable provides stability and angled cutting capability.
- Integrated LED work light enhances visibility for precise cuts.
- Dust port helps maintain a clean workspace.
- Variable speed control accommodates different materials.
4.6/5
Check Price on Amazon
1.2 Amp Corded 16 in. Scroll Saw
- Arrives new in box with all accessories.
- Tool-free blade changes for convenience.
- Supports both plain and pin-end blades.
- Integrated dust blower enhances visibility.
4.6/5
Check Price on Amazon
Dremel MS20-01 Moto-Saw Variable Speed Compact Scr
- Effective dust port for a clean work area.
- Auto-tensioning quick-change blade mechanism.
- Variable speed control enhances material versatility.
- Detachable coping function for handheld use.
4.7/5
Check Price on Amazon
Detailed Reviews of the Best Scroll Saws
WEN Variable Speed Scroll Saw – Accepts blades in two directions for increased ripping capacity.
This scroll saw offers a good range of features for both hobbyists and more experienced woodworkers. The ability to accept blades in two directions significantly expands ripping capabilities. The variable speed control, ranging from 400 to 1600 SPM, provides flexibility for working with various materials and thicknesses.
The 16×11 inch table that bevels up to 45 degrees allows for angled cuts, adding versatility to your projects. It can cut wood up to 2 inches thick with a 16-inch throat depth in the standard position. Tool-free blade changes via a thumb screw adapter, a cast iron base for stability, an air pump to keep the cutting line clear, a flex light for illumination, and a dust port for cleanup are all welcome additions.
The foot lock clamp is a nice safety measure, and the included onboard storage and three blades add value.
Pros
- Accepts blades in two directions for increased ripping capacity.
- Variable speed control (400-1600 SPM) for versatile material cutting.
- Tilting table (up to 45 degrees) for angled cuts.
- Tool-free blade changes.
- Cast iron base for stability.
- Integrated features: air pump, flex light, dust port.
Cons
- Cutting depth is limited to 2 inches.
- The onboard storage capacity might be limited for larger accessories.
DEWALT Scroll Saw, 1.3 Amp – Reduced vibration due to double parallel-link arm.
This scroll saw boasts several features designed to enhance precision and user experience. The double parallel-link arm is likely effective in minimizing vibration, which should contribute to cleaner cuts. The tool-free blade clamps are a definite plus, promising quick and easy blade changes.
The placement of controls – on/off switch, variable speed, dust blower, and blade-tensioning lever – on the front arm is convenient and promotes ease of use. The arm’s pivoting design and lifting capability seem well-thought-out for smoother operation and internal cuts, respectively. Overall, the design appears focused on user-friendliness and precision.
Pros
- Reduced vibration due to double parallel-link arm.
- Tool-free blade clamps for fast blade changes.
- Conveniently located front arm controls.
- Pivoting arm design promotes smoother operation.
- Arm lift allows easy blade threading for inside cuts.
Cons
- The actual effectiveness of vibration reduction needs to be tested in real-world use.
- Longevity and durability of tool-free blade clamps are unknown.
WEN 3922 16-inch Variable Speed Scroll Saw with Ea – Easy blade changes with side panel access and tool-free adapter.
This scroll saw offers a range of features designed for both ease of use and versatility. The standout feature is undoubtedly the side panel for quick blade changes, complemented by a tool-free blade adapter. The variable speed control, ranging from 550 to 1600 SPM, allows for adaptability across different materials and project complexities.
The 16×10 inch table, which bevels up to 45 degrees, provides ample space and angled cutting capabilities. Its 2-inch cutting capacity and 16-inch throat depth are suitable for a variety of woodworking tasks. Additional features like the cast iron base, air pump, and dust port enhance stability, visibility, and cleanliness.
The inclusion of three 5-inch blades is a nice starting point.
Pros
- Easy blade changes with side panel access and tool-free adapter.
- Variable speed control allows for versatility with different materials.
- Beveling table provides angled cutting capabilities.
- Cast iron base enhances stability.
- Air pump and dust port improve visibility and cleanliness.
Cons
- Only three 5-inch blades included; users may need to purchase more for extensive use.
- Foot lock clamp might require adjustments for optimal security.
WEN Variable Speed Scroll Saw – Tool-free blade changes via side panel access
This scroll saw offers a range of features that cater to both beginners and experienced users. The variable speed control (550-1600 SPM) provides versatility for different materials, and the 16-inch throat depth is adequate for many projects. The tool-free blade change mechanism and side panel access significantly simplify blade replacement.
The 16×10 inch table with a 45-degree bevel adds to its usability for angled cuts. While the included features like the air pump and dust port are welcome additions for maintaining a clean work environment, users should be aware that the included blades are a basic set and may need replacing for more specialized work. The cast iron base lends stability, and the foot lock clamp enhances safety.
Pros
- Tool-free blade changes via side panel access
- Variable speed control for different materials
- Spacious table with beveling capability
- Adequate 16-inch throat depth
- Cast iron base for stability
- Includes air pump and dust port
Cons
- Included blades are basic and may require upgrading
- 2-inch cutting capacity may be limiting for some projects
Shop Fox W1872 16″ VS Scroll Saw with Foot Switch – Variable speed motor offers flexibility.
This scroll saw offers a decent set of features for hobbyists and DIY enthusiasts. The 1/6 HP motor seems adequate for most common tasks, and the variable speed control (550-1600 SPM) provides flexibility for working with different materials. The 16-inch cutting width is a definite plus, allowing for larger projects.
The 2-1/4 inch cutting thickness is fairly standard. The cast-aluminum table with its -5 to 45 degree tilt capability enhances versatility for angled cuts. The 1-1/4 inch dust port is a welcome addition for maintaining a cleaner workspace.
Inclusion of a pin-less blade adapter expands blade compatibility.
Pros
- Variable speed motor offers flexibility.
- 16-inch cutting width is suitable for larger projects.
- Tilting table for angled cuts.
- Includes dust port for dust collection.
- Pin-less blade adapter increases blade options.
Cons
- 1/6 HP motor might be underpowered for very dense materials or prolonged use.
- Cutting thickness of 2-1/4″ might limit some projects.
FOXBC 5-Inch Scroll Saw Blade Pin End Replacement for Wen 3921 3923 – Wide compatibility with various scroll saw models.
This 48-pack of 5-inch pin end scroll saw blades offers a variety of TPI options (10, 15, 18, and 24) suitable for cutting various materials like wood, plastic, and soft metals. The blades are constructed from SK5 Japanese carbon steel, promising enhanced durability and resistance to corrosion. They are designed as replacements for several popular scroll saw brands and models including WEN, Dremel, and Craftsman, among others.
The ease of installation and use is a key selling point. While the quantity is generous and the variety is useful, the long-term performance and sharpness retention of the blades will ultimately determine their value. Users should test each TPI on their specific material to optimize cutting performance.
Pros
- Wide compatibility with various scroll saw models.
- Includes a good assortment of TPI (10, 15, 18, 24) for versatile cutting.
- Constructed from SK5 Japanese carbon steel for improved strength and corrosion resistance.
- Easy to install and use.
- Comes in a generous 48-pack quantity.
Cons
- Long-term sharpness retention is unknown; requires testing.
- Pin end design may not be compatible with all scroll saws.
WEN LL2156 21-Inch 1.6-Amp Variable Speed Parallel Arm Scroll Saw with Extra-Large Dual-Bevel Steel Table – Parallel-arm design reduces vibration and noise.
This scroll saw appears to be a decent option for hobbyists and DIYers. The parallel-arm design and steel construction suggest a focus on minimizing vibration and noise, which is a plus for prolonged use. The tilting table offers versatility for angled cuts, and the tool-free blade changes should streamline the workflow.
The inclusion of features like a variable speed motor, air pump, and dust port are welcome additions. The two-year warranty provides some peace of mind. However, the 1.6-amp motor might be underpowered for very thick or dense materials.
The included pinless blades and adjustable hold-down clamp are convenient for getting started.
Pros
- Parallel-arm design reduces vibration and noise.
- Tilting table provides versatility for angled cuts.
- Tool-free blade changes simplify the process.
- Variable speed motor allows for material-specific adjustments.
- Integrated air pump helps clear the cutting line.
- Includes a two-year warranty.
Cons
- The 1.6-amp motor might struggle with thicker materials.
- Stroke length may be limiting for some projects.
Hipicute 16-Inch Variable Speed Scroll Saw with Tilting Worktable (0-45°) – Large adjustable worktable provides stability and angled cutting capability.
This 16-inch scroll saw offers a good balance of features for both hobbyists and professionals working on detailed projects. The adjustable steel worktable, tilting up to 45 degrees, provides stability and flexibility for angled cuts. The integrated LED work light significantly improves visibility, crucial for intricate work.
The dust blower and port are a welcome addition, helping to maintain a cleaner workspace and potentially prolonging the saw’s life. The variable speed control, ranging from 500 to 1,600 SPM, allows for customization based on the material being cut. Overall, it appears to be a well-rounded tool suitable for various materials and projects.
Pros
- Large adjustable worktable provides stability and angled cutting capability.
- Integrated LED work light enhances visibility for precise cuts.
- Dust port helps maintain a clean workspace.
- Variable speed control accommodates different materials.
- Suitable for both hobbyists and professionals.
Cons
- Steel table, while stable, may not be as durable as cast iron for heavy use.
- Dust blower effectiveness may vary depending on the fineness of the material being cut.
1.2 Amp Corded 16 in. Scroll Saw – Arrives new in box with all accessories.
This scroll saw appears to be a standard model, arriving new in box with all necessary accessories for immediate use. The tool-free blade change system is a convenient feature, simplifying the process of swapping between plain and pin-end blades. The integrated dust blower is a practical addition, helping to maintain a clear view of the cutting line.
Initial observations suggest ease of use and standard functionality. However, further testing would be needed to assess its long-term durability and precision, as well as the effectiveness of the dust blower in various cutting conditions and materials. The tool claims to be easy to use and ready to be operated right out of the box.
Pros
- Arrives new in box with all accessories.
- Tool-free blade changes for convenience.
- Supports both plain and pin-end blades.
- Integrated dust blower enhances visibility.
Cons
- Long-term durability and precision not yet assessed.
- Effectiveness of dust blower under various conditions needs confirmation.
Dremel MS20-01 Moto-Saw Variable Speed Compact Scr – Effective dust port for a clean work area.
This scroll saw offers a range of features designed to improve user experience and versatility. The dust port adapter is a welcome addition, helping to maintain a cleaner workspace and better visibility of the cutting line. The auto-tensioning quick-change mechanism simplifies blade changes, and the variable speed control is useful for working with different materials.
The detachable coping function adds to its flexibility, allowing for handheld use. However, it is important to note that the blue edge guide locking levers illustrated on the packaging are *not* included. While the manufacturer assures that this doesn’t affect the tool’s performance, it might be disappointing for some customers expecting a complete package.
The fast-clamp base appears to offer secure attachment to various surfaces.
Pros
- Effective dust port for a clean work area.
- Auto-tensioning quick-change blade mechanism.
- Variable speed control enhances material versatility.
- Detachable coping function for handheld use.
- Fast-clamp base for secure mounting.
Cons
- Blue edge guide locking levers (illustrated on packaging) are not included.
Buying Guide: What to Look For in a Best Scroll Saws
Understanding Scroll Saws
Scroll saws are specialized power tools designed for intricate and delicate cutting tasks. They use a fine, reciprocating blade to create curves, shapes, and detailed designs in materials like wood, plastic, and thin metal. Choosing the best scroll saw depends on your specific needs, project types, and skill level. This buying guide helps you navigate the features and factors to consider before investing in a scroll saw.
Key Features to Consider
When selecting the best scroll saw, consider several essential features. Variable speed control is crucial for adapting to different materials. Look for a saw with a wide speed range (e.g., 400-1600 SPM). Tool-free blade changes significantly speed up workflow. A tilting table allows for angled cuts, expanding your project possibilities. Stability is important; a cast iron base reduces vibration. Integrated features like an air pump, dust port, and work light improve visibility and cleanliness. Finally, throat depth determines the maximum width of material you can cut.
Types of Blades and Blade Compatibility
Scroll saws can accept pin-end or plain-end (pin-less) blades. Pin-end blades are easier to install but limit your options. Pin-less blades offer more versatility and finer cuts, but require adapters on some models. Consider the availability and cost of blades for your chosen saw. A good assortment of TPI (Teeth Per Inch) is essential for cutting different materials and thicknesses. Also, look into the option to use a foot switch, which lets you have both hands free.
Motor and Vibration Reduction
The motor’s amperage indicates its power. A higher amperage generally means a more powerful saw. Vibration can significantly impact precision and comfort. Look for features like parallel-link arm designs or pivoting arms designed to reduce vibration. A stable base, preferably cast iron, also contributes to minimizing vibration. Reduced vibration leads to cleaner cuts and less fatigue, especially during longer projects. Selecting the best scroll saw means considering its motor power and vibration dampening features.
Ergonomics and Ease of Use
Ergonomics play a vital role in your overall experience. Consider the placement of controls, ease of blade changes, and the comfort of the handle. A clear view of the cutting line is essential, so features like an integrated air pump and work light are valuable. Some saws offer a detachable coping function for handheld use, adding to their versatility. The best scroll saw will feel comfortable and intuitive to use, allowing you to focus on your craft.
Budget and Warranty
Scroll saws range in price from budget-friendly models to professional-grade machines. Determine your budget and prioritize the features that are most important to you. A longer warranty indicates the manufacturer’s confidence in their product. Consider the cost of replacement blades and accessories when making your decision. The best scroll saw offers a balance of features, performance, and value for your money.
Frequently Asked Questions about Best Scroll Saws
What is the difference between a scroll saw and a band saw?
A scroll saw is designed for intricate, detailed cuts in thinner materials like wood, plastic, and thin metal. It uses a reciprocating blade that moves up and down. A band saw is used for cutting thicker materials and making straight or curved cuts. It uses a continuous loop blade. Scroll saws are better for detail work, while band saws are better for resawing and general cutting tasks. Deciding which is the best scroll saw depends on the types of project you are planning.
What does SPM mean when referring to scroll saws?
SPM stands for Strokes Per Minute. It refers to the number of times the blade moves up and down in one minute. A higher SPM generally means a faster cutting speed. Variable speed control, measured in SPM, is an important feature in a scroll saw because it allows you to adjust the cutting speed to match the material you are working with. Softer materials may require a higher SPM, while harder materials may require a lower SPM to prevent burning or damaging the blade.
What is throat depth and why is it important?
Throat depth is the distance from the blade to the back of the saw frame. It determines the maximum width of the material you can cut. For example, a 16-inch scroll saw has a throat depth of 16 inches, meaning you can cut a piece of wood up to 16 inches wide. If you plan to work on larger projects, you will need a scroll saw with a greater throat depth. Consider the size of your typical projects when choosing the best scroll saw for your needs.
What are the benefits of a tilting table on a scroll saw?
A tilting table allows you to make angled cuts, also known as bevel cuts. This is useful for creating decorative edges, joinery, and other intricate designs. Most scroll saws have a table that can tilt up to 45 degrees in one or both directions. A tilting table expands the versatility of your scroll saw and allows you to create a wider range of projects. When choosing the best scroll saw, consider how often you will need to make angled cuts.
Are tool-free blade changes really necessary?
Tool-free blade changes are a very convenient feature that can save you time and effort. With a tool-free system, you can quickly and easily change blades without needing any additional tools. This is especially useful if you frequently switch between different types of blades for different materials or cutting techniques. While not strictly necessary, tool-free blade changes are a valuable feature that can improve your workflow.
What is the purpose of an air pump and dust port on a scroll saw?
The air pump and dust port are designed to improve visibility and cleanliness. The air pump blows away dust and debris from the cutting line, allowing you to see your work more clearly. The dust port connects to a vacuum cleaner or dust collection system, which helps to remove dust from the work area. These features help to keep your workspace clean and safe, and they improve the accuracy of your cuts.
What are the advantages of a cast iron base on a scroll saw?
A cast iron base provides stability and reduces vibration. Cast iron is a heavy and dense material that absorbs vibrations, resulting in smoother and more accurate cuts. A stable base also prevents the saw from moving around during operation, which can be dangerous. While scroll saws with plastic bases are available, a cast iron base is generally preferred for its superior stability and vibration reduction.
What type of blades should I use with my scroll saw?
The type of blade you should use depends on the material you are cutting and the type of cut you want to make. Finer blades with more teeth per inch (TPI) are better for intricate cuts in thinner materials. Coarser blades with fewer TPI are better for thicker materials. Scroll saw blades are available in a variety of materials, including high-speed steel, carbon steel, and spiral blades. Experiment with different blades to find what works best for your needs.
How important is variable speed control on a scroll saw?
Variable speed control is a very important feature on a scroll saw. It allows you to adjust the cutting speed to match the material you are working with. Softer materials may require a higher speed, while harder materials may require a lower speed to prevent burning or damaging the blade. Variable speed control also allows you to control the aggressiveness of the cut, which is important for creating precise and detailed designs.
What is the difference between pin-end and pin-less blades?
Pin-end blades have small pins at each end that fit into slots on the scroll saw. They are easy to install and remove, but they are not as versatile as pin-less blades. Pin-less blades do not have pins and are held in place by clamps. They offer more flexibility and allow you to make finer cuts, but they can be more difficult to install. Consider the types of projects you will be working on when choosing between pin-end and pin-less blades.
Conclusion: The Final Verdict
The WEN Variable Speed Scroll Saw overall, this scroll saw provides a solid set of features for a variety of woodworking tasks. its innovative blade direction and variable speed make it a worthwhile option for those looking for versatility and convenience. i would recommend this product for both beginners and intermediate users.
